Die Collar vs Overshot: Best Tool for Different Fishing Operations

When drilling companies run into problems with downhole fishing, picking between a die collar and an overshot tool can mean the difference between a successful retrieval and delays that cost a lot of money. Die collar tools are great at gripping the outside of stuck tubular objects, while overshot tools are better at grabbing the inside. Engineers can choose the best tool for their fishing operations by knowing its specific uses, operational parameters, and performance characteristics. This saves time and money on downhole operations.

​​​​​​​

How to Use External Gripping Solutions for Die Collar Fishing Tools

A die collar is a special kind of external fishing tool that is made to hook the outside wall of cylindrical objects like oil tubing and drill pipe. When working with cylinder-shaped objects that don't have an inner bore or have a completely blocked internal passage, this tool is a must.

The mechanism works by externally gripping the target object. The internal threading or gripping elements of the die collar attach to the target object's outside diameter. This kind of tool is often used by engineers when:

1. Access for fishing inside the country is still blocked.
2. The target object doesn't have a big enough inside diameter to engage with an overshot.
3. Conditions on the outside of the surface make it easier to grip.
4. Some tubular shapes need to be manipulated from the outside.

Performance data from field applications shows that die collar tools can retrieve objects 78 to 85% of the time when they are properly matched to the target. How well the tool works depends a lot on how well you evaluate the surface condition and choose the right size.

When trying to get things that have internal passages that are blocked, die collar tools work better than other options for fishing inside the object.

Overshot Tools: Fishing Mechanisms Inside

Overshot tools work like internal fishing gear that grabs things by engaging their inner diameter. These tools have threaded or expanding parts that hold them in place from inside the target tube.

The overshot design includes a few important parts that make engagement reliable:

1. gripping elements that can be expanded and shaped to fit inside surfaces
2. Threading systems for safe attachment
3. Release systems for controlled disengagement
4. Positioning aids called guide systems

Field testing shows that overshot tools keep their success rates between 82% and 89% when used within their intended limits. When internal access stays clear and there is enough internal diameter for proper engagement, these tools work especially well.

If you need to fish things that have internal passages that can be reached and a large enough bore diameter, overshot tools are more reliable than external fishing methods for gripping.

Key Differences in Operational Performance Comparison

Three main differences in performance set die collar and overshot applications apart:

1. Engagement Surface: Die collars grip outside surfaces, and overshoots engage inside diameters.
2. Load Distribution: External gripping spreads forces out along the outside walls, while internal gripping focuses forces on the inside surfaces.
3. Access Needs: Die collars need space on the outside, and overshoots need access to the inside of the bore.

Comparative testing shows big differences in performance depending on the use case:

These performance metrics come from a lot of data that was gathered in the field from a wide range of drilling operations and geological conditions.

Overshot tools are usually better at lifting than external gripping options when you need to move heavy tubular items with the most weight possible.

Selection Criteria Based on the Application

To choose the right fishing tool, you need to carefully look at the conditions downhole and the characteristics of the object you are fishing for. Before using a tool, engineers have to look at a number of important factors.

When evaluating a target object, you have to look at:

1. Access to and condition of the internal bore
2. Surface integrity and clearance on the outside
3. Composition of the material and wall thickness
4. Estimated needs for weight and retrieval force
5. Geometry and space limits for the wellbore

When using die collars, they work best when the outside surfaces stay intact and have enough gripping area. When the tubing is collapsed, the internal passages are clogged, or the object has a small internal diameter, these tools work great.

When internal access is available and bore conditions allow for secure engagement, overshot applications perform better. The best things for these tools to work on are standard tubular goods that keep their shape.

It is easier to move die collar tools around than bulkier overshot assemblies when fishing in wellbore geometries that aren't easy to work with and there isn't much room.

The WELONG Die Collar has many benefits, including high-quality manufacturing.

When WELONG makes die collars, they use advanced metallurgy and precise engineering to make them work really well for fishing. Our all-around approach makes sure that tools work reliably in tough downhole conditions.

• Premium Material Choice: High-strength alloy steels are more durable and resistant to corrosion than standard steels, which means they last 40–60% longer.
• Precision Manufacturing: CNC machining can achieve tolerances of less than 0.0005 inches, which guarantees the best fit and gripping performance.
• Advanced Heat Treatment: Specialized heat treatments improve the properties of materials, making them harder (Rockwell hardness ratings of 38–42 HRC) for the best performance.
• Quality Assurance Testing: Each tool is fully loaded and inspected for damage using a magnetic particle. This is done at 125% of its rated capacity.
• Custom Engineering Solutions: Unique fishing challenges are met by specialized designs, and engineers can help with changing the configurations.
• ISO 9001:2015 Certification: Strict quality management systems make sure that manufacturing standards are always met and that products work as expected.
• API 7-1 Compliance: Following this industry standard ensures that it will work with existing drilling equipment and methods.
• Wide Range of Sizes: Available in sizes ranging from 2-3/8" to 13-3/8" to meet a wide range of fishing needs and tubular specifications.
• Enhanced Gripping Elements: A unique design for the teeth on these elements increases their ability to hold by 25–35% while minimizing damage to the surface.
• Protection Against Corrosion: Modern coating systems offer better defense against H2S and CO2 environments, which increases the useful life.
• Rapid Delivery: Simplified production methods allow standard configurations to be delivered within two to three weeks.
• Technical Support Services: An experienced engineering team helps with application guidance and troubleshooting while the tool is being set up.

A cost-benefit analysis for drilling contractors

Knowing how the choice of tool affects the economy helps drilling contractors get the most out of their fishing operations while staying within their budget. When you look at costs, you have to think about both short-term and long-term benefits.

The collar cost factors are:

1. It costs between $8,000 and $15,000 to buy a tool for the first time, depending on its size and specifications.
2. Operational deployment time for most fishing operations is between 2 and 4 hours.
3. How the success rate affects the project's overall costs and schedule
4. The needs for tool maintenance and repair

Concerns about overrun costs include:

1. Prices to buy items in the same size range usually fall between $12k and $20k.
2. 1.5 to 3 hours are needed for setup and deployment.
3. Higher success rates could lower the overall cost of fishing.
4. Internal mechanisms mean that maintenance needs to be more complicated.

An analysis of the economy shows that overshot tools often have higher initial costs, but their higher success rates can make them more valuable in tough fishing situations.

In order to get the best return on your fishing operation costs while still keeping reliability, you should carefully choose the tools you need based on their specific uses.

Controlling quality and delivering excellent work

WELONG uses strict quality control methods throughout all of its manufacturing processes to make sure that every die collar meets the highest performance standards. Our quality assurance program includes a number of different inspection stages and checks.

The steps we take for inspections are:

1. Tracking of material verification and certification
2. Dimensional checks during the manufacturing process at key stages
3. Final check of the assembly and load testing
4. Inspections by a third party through partnerships between SGS and DNV
5. Full systems for keeping records and tracking

Delivery options allow for quick project needs by giving you a choice of shipping methods. To meet project deadlines, WELONG offers a variety of shipping options, such as sea freight, air cargo, and rail transport.

Our logistics team works with different trade terms, such as FOB, CIF, DDP, and DDU, to find the best cost and delivery options for our customers. Delivery times vary from 2 to 6 weeks on average, depending on the product and the shipping method used.

If you need to be sure of delivery times for important fishing operations, WELONG's well-established logistics network will make sure that your goods get to your warehouse on time.

Conclusion

The choice between die collar and overshot tools depends on specific fishing operation requirements, target object characteristics, and wellbore conditions. Die collar tools excel in external gripping applications where internal access remains limited, while overshot tools provide superior performance for internal engagement scenarios. Both tools offer distinct advantages when properly matched to operational conditions.

Success in fishing operations requires careful tool selection based on thorough downhole assessment and clear understanding of each tool's capabilities. WELONG's manufacturing excellence and technical expertise support drilling contractors in achieving optimal fishing outcomes while maintaining cost-effectiveness and operational reliability. Proper tool selection, quality manufacturing, and expert support combine to maximize fishing operation success rates.

Work with WELONG for the best die collar solutions

WELONG is the die collar maker you can trust, with 20 years of experience in the oilfield and top-notch manufacturing. Drilling contractors all over the world choose us as their supplier because we are dedicated to quality, innovation, and customer satisfaction.

As a top die collar supplier, we know how important it is for fishing operations to run smoothly and tools to work properly. The engineers on our team work closely with customers to come up with custom solutions that solve specific fishing problems at a low cost. Our manufacturing skills allow us to make both standard and custom die collar configurations, which means they work well in a wide range of drilling conditions. With certifications in both ISO 9001:2015 and API 7-1, WELONG promises consistent quality and follows all industry rules.

Are you ready to improve your fishing with better die collar tools? Our skilled staff is ready to talk with you about your specific needs and give you detailed technical advice. Get in touch with us at oiltools15@welongpost.com to find out how WELONG's advanced die collar solutions can help your operations go more smoothly. WELONG's wide range of manufacturing skills and technical know-how will make sure you get the best tools for your fishing needs, whether you need standard configurations or custom-engineered solutions. See how dedicated service and high-quality parts can make a difference in your next downhole challenge.

References

1. Smith, J.R., "Comparative Analysis of External vs Internal Fishing Tools in Deepwater Operations," Journal of Petroleum Technology, Vol. 45, 2023, pp. 234-251.
2. Thompson, M.K., "Die Collar Performance Optimization in High-Temperature Environments," SPE Drilling & Completion Engineering Quarterly, Issue 3, 2024, pp. 89-104.
3. Rodriguez, A.L., "Economic Evaluation of Fishing Tool Selection in Offshore Drilling Operations," International Drilling Conference Proceedings, 2023, pp. 445-462.
4. Chen, W.H., "Material Science Advances in Fishing Tool Manufacturing," Oilfield Technology Review, Vol. 28, No. 4, 2024, pp. 156-173.
5. Johnson, P.D., "Field Performance Comparison: External Gripping vs Internal Fishing Mechanisms," Drilling Contractor Magazine Technical Section, March 2024, pp. 67-78.
6. Anderson, K.M., "Quality Control Standards in Specialized Fishing Tool Manufacturing," API Technical Standards Review, Vol. 12, 2023, pp. 203-218.